The 2020-2024 Council resolved to separate waste rates from general rates, as one of the actions from the Financial Sustainability Strategy. At the time, council chose a simple separation, retaining fees that scale with property value (waste rates) instead of changing to fixed fees per household (waste charges).
The 2024-2028 Council resolved to cap any increase to the waste rates at the rate cap, and is looking at options to change from waste rates to waste charges. However, changing from waste rates to waste charges will impact each household differently, depending upon the value of their property (house + land).
Property values in Yarra
There are approximately 53,000 rateable residential properties in the City of Yarra, and each has a Capital Improved Value (CIV) set annually by the state Valuer-General. The CIV value for each property (using data from the City of Yarra) can be displayed as a histogram, to see how the values are spread.

The median value is $780,000. That means that half the properties in Yarra have a lower value, and half have a higher value. If your house and land is worth more, it means you’re in the top half of Yarra. If you own more than one property, that moves you higher up on the wealth spectrum.
Converting CIV to rates
The rates payable by any property can be estimated by looking at the factors on your rates bill:
- Net Annual Value (NAV) is 5% of Capital Improved Value (CIV)
- General Rates are 3.60% of NAV
- Waste Rates (household) are 0.649% of NAV (pickup of bins from your house)
- Waste Rates (public) are 0.202% of NAV (pickup of bins from public parks)
- State levy (fixed) $139 per household
- State levy (rate) 0.0173% of CIV
The rates payable by the median, 10%, and 1% properties are:
- median ($0.78 million) pays about $2,000 in total rates, including general rates, waste rates, and state charges
- top 10% ($1.86 million) pays about $4,600 in total rates
- top 1% ($3.2 million) pays about $7,800 in total rates

Impact of changing to a waste charge
We can model the effect of changing from a waste rate (the fee scales with property value) to a waste charge (the fee is the same for each property) by calculating a revenue-neutral fixed fee.
The chart below adds a red line to show the impact on properties with different values, assuming a change from waste rates to a waste charge, and assuming that all residential properties pay for waste collection. The outcome is that lower value properties pay more, and higher value properties pay less.
- the median property pays $60 more
- the 10% property pays $290 less
- the 1% property pays $720 less

Note: we know that not all properties pay a waste rate, because some properties are in multi-unit developments with private waste collection. However, we don’t know which ones. So, we don’t claim that the model is 100% accurate. Either way, the simple model shown above (assuming every property pays for waste collection) is conceptually correct at showing how the impact varies for different property values.
Our view
The cost of kerbside waste collection can be recovered through either a waste rate or a waste charge. Different councils use different methods, and a decision on which to use can be guided by personal values (e.g. freedom, equality, social justice, responsibility, and a world of beauty), including those described in Yarra’s Community Vision and Social Justice Charter. A change to a waste rate will have the following impact:
- higher costs for owners of lower value properties
- lower costs for owners of higher value properties
Before Yarra considers any change, we urge Council to publish their own modelling, showing the impact on different properties, to enable ratepayers to understand the impact on both themselves and others.